View Single Post
Old 11th August 2007, 09:10   #142 (permalink)
Pete Exxtreme
Lick it up
 
Pete Exxtreme's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Thonon/France
Posts: 4,635
Send a message via MSN to Pete Exxtreme
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sketchy View Post
That's the whole point of buying "other" apps these days. It's not like you buy one and that's it. You have to spend another couple hundred bucks of learning materials just to figure how the ui works. Not to mention the time it takes to do all these things. Time is precious. In Carrara all you need is the pdf documentation that goes with it.

I can have the most expensive 3d app in the world and end up not producing anything from it. How many people (not big studios) who own any of these apps (Lightwave, XSI, Maya, Max) could even produce a 20 sec animation similar to one of Elephants Dream's? I just don't know of any to this day. Do you?
I agree but buying extra book for application does not mean that this other app is more complicated.
Carrara doc is quite poor in its content : do you see serious examples on "How to build a a shader", or "how unwrap a real objet".?
like the other embedded app doc, it's more a reference manual than a user's manual. That's where some extra books are usefull, as thay are focused on a particular subject.
With Carrara you can produce something fast, probably faster than most of the 3D app, but you when you want to go further, then you have to discoverer everything on your own.

Otherwise i strongely agree when you say than it's not the 3D app that makes the artist
__________________
Toute faute de frappe ou erreur de syntaxe sont dues a un clavier rebelle ŕ toute forme d'autorité.

LightWave 9
| Hexagon 2
My gallery

Pete Exxtreme is offline   Reply With Quote