|
Well, I am not trying to make this a trueSpace versus Carrara war, as I do use both programs. We could have a philosophical argument over how a pen is nothing like a pencil but it would be of no use.
Most of your responses to things that I have said seem to be from an interpretation of what you think I mean rather than the context in which I am saying it.
I don't see where anything in that quote from me can be construed as mischievous (which I think is a pretty harsh and disproportionate term to use when we are just talking about a 3D app). If you go back and look at the way you refer to the program, you will see that you have given a lot more virulent evaluation of Carrara than I gave to trueSpace in this thread.
I have said this before a number of times as it was said to me:
The music is not in the piano.
Regardless of which program you use, it will be your ability to execute your vision that makes great art. Nothing more.
The most important thing that a company can do to help the artist execute his vision is to ensure their product performs as advertised. Caligari is doing a very good job of making trueSpace a program that performs as advertised, but there are still areas that need fine tuning and others that still need constructing. That isn't a slight against the company, it is a real issue that someone giving an honest evaluation to a consumer should mention.
Over on the Caligari forums, a new user got stuck following a nurbs tutorial and I helped out. I'd do the same thing for anyone here who was trying out the demo (as I am sure you would do). So for anyone who really wants to compare the two, download the demo of tS and/or Carrara and post some questions in a thread.
Someone will have an answer...
|